Broadband Multi-wavelength Properties of M87 during the 2017 Event Horizon Telescope Campaign

DOI: 
10.3847/2041-8213/abef71
Publication date: 
24/04/2021
Main author: 
EHT MWL Science Working Group
IAA authors: 
Alberdi, Antxon;Fuentes, Antonio;Gómez, José L.;Lico, Rocco;Zhao, Guang-Yao
Authors: 
EHT MWL Science Working Group;Algaba, J. C.;Anczarski, J.;Asada, K.;Baloković, M.;Chandra, S.;Cui, Y. -Z.;Falcone, A. D.;Giroletti, M.;Goddi, C.;Hada, K.;Haggard, D.;Jorstad, S.;Kaur, A.;Kawashima, T.;Keating, G.;Kim, J. -Y.;Kino, M.;Komossa, S.;Kravchenko, E. V.;Krichbaum, T. P.;Lee, S. -S.;Lu, R. -S.;Lucchini, M.;Markoff, S.;Neilsen, J.;Nowak, M. A.;Park, J.;Principe, G.;Ramakrishnan, V.;Reynolds, M. T.;Sasada, M.;Savchenko, S. S.;Williamson, K. E.;Event Horizon Telescope Collaboration;Akiyama, Kazunori;Alberdi, Antxon;Alef, Walter;Anantua, Richard;Azulay, Rebecca;Baczko, Anne-Kathrin;Ball, David;Barrett, John;Bintley, Dan;Benson, Bradford A.;Blackburn, Lindy;Blundell, Raymond;Boland, Wilfred;Bouman, Katherine L.;Bower, Geoffrey C.;Boyce, Hope;Bremer, Michael;Brinkerink, Christiaan D.;Brissenden, Roger;Britzen, Silke;Broderick, Avery E.;Broguiere, Dominique;Bronzwaer, Thomas;Byun, Do-Young;Carlstrom, John E.;Chael, Andrew;Chan, Chi-Kwan;Chatterjee, Shami;Chatterjee, Koushik;Chen, Ming-Tang;Chen, Yongjun;Chesler, Paul M.;Cho, Ilje;Christian, Pierre;Conway, John E.;Cordes, James M.;Crawford, Thomas M.;Crew, Geoffrey B.;Cruz-Osorio, Alejandro;Davelaar, Jordy;de Laurentis, Mariafelicia;Deane, Roger;Dempsey, Jessica;Desvignes, Gregory;Dexter, Jason;Doeleman, Sheperd S.;Eatough, Ralph P.;Falcke, Heino;Farah, Joseph;Fish, Vincent L.;Fomalont, Ed;Ford, H. Alyson;Fraga-Encinas, Raquel;Friberg, Per;Fromm, Christian M.;Fuentes, Antonio;Galison, Peter;Gammie, Charles F.;García, Roberto;Gentaz, Olivier;Georgiev, Boris;Gold, Roman;Gómez, José L.;Gómez-Ruiz, Arturo I.;Gu, Minfeng;Gurwell, Mark;Hecht, Michael H.;Hesper, Ronald;Ho, Luis C.;Ho, Paul;Honma, Mareki;Huang, Chih-Wei L.;Huang, Lei;Hughes, David H.;Ikeda, Shiro;Inoue, Makoto;Issaoun, Sara;James, David J.;Jannuzi, Buell T.;Janssen, Michael;Jeter, Britton;Jiang, Wu;Jiménez-Rosales, Alejandra;Johnson, Michael D.;Jung, Taehyun;Karami, Mansour;Karuppusamy, Ramesh;Kettenis, Mark;Kim, Dong-Jin;Kim, Jongsoo;Kim, Junhan;Koay, Jun Yi;Kofuji, Yutaro;Koch, Patrick M.;Koyama, Shoko;Kramer, Michael;Kramer, Carsten;Kuo, Cheng-Yu;Lauer, Tod R.;Levis, Aviad;Li, Yan-Rong;Li, Zhiyuan;Lindqvist, Michael;Lico, Rocco;Lindahl, Greg;Liu, Jun;Liu, Kuo;Liuzzo, Elisabetta;Lo, Wen-Ping;Lobanov, Andrei P.;Loinard, Laurent;Lonsdale, Colin;MacDonald, Nicholas R.;Mao, Jirong;Marchili, Nicola;Marrone, Daniel P.;Marscher, Alan P.;Martí-Vidal, Iván;Matsushita, Satoki;Matthews, Lynn D.;Medeiros, Lia;Menten, Karl M.;Mizuno, Izumi;Mizuno, Yosuke;Moran, James M.;Moriyama, Kotaro;Moscibrodzka, Monika;Müller, Cornelia;Musoke, Gibwa;Mejías, Alejandro Mus;Nagai, Hiroshi;Nagar, Neil M.;Nakamura, Masanori;Narayan, Ramesh;Narayanan, Gopal;Natarajan, Iniyan;Nathanail, Antonios;Neri, Roberto;Ni, Chunchong;Noutsos, Aristeidis;Okino, Hiroki;Olivares, Héctor;Ortiz-León, Gisela N.;Oyama, Tomoaki;Özel, Feryal;Palumbo, Daniel C. M.;Patel, Nimesh;Pen, Ue-Li;Pesce, Dominic W.;Piétu, Vincent;Plambeck, Richard;Popstefanija, Aleksandar;Porth, Oliver;Pötzl, Felix M.;Prather, Ben;Preciado-López, Jorge A.;Psaltis, Dimitrios;Pu, Hung-Yi;Rao, Ramprasad;Rawlings, Mark G.;Raymond, Alexander W.;Rezzolla, Luciano;Ricarte, Angelo;Ripperda, Bart;Roelofs, Freek;Rogers, Alan;Ros, Eduardo;Rose, Mel;Roshanineshat, Arash;Rottmann, Helge;Roy, Alan L.;Ruszczyk, Chet;Rygl, Kazi L. J.;Sánchez, Salvador;Sánchez-Arguelles, David;Savolainen, Tuomas;Schloerb, F. Peter;Schuster, Karl-Friedrich;Shao, Lijing;Shen, Zhiqiang;Small, Des;Sohn, Bong Won;Soohoo, Jason;Sun, He;Tazaki, Fumie;Tetarenko, Alexandra J.;Tiede, Paul;Tilanus, Remo P. J.;Titus, Michael;Toma, Kenji;Torne, Pablo;Trent, Tyler;Traianou, Efthalia;Trippe, Sascha;van Bemmel, Ilse;van Langevelde, Huib Jan;van Rossum, Daniel R.;Wagner, Jan;Ward-Thompson, Derek;Wardle, John;Weintroub, Jonathan;Wex, Norbert;Wharton, Robert;Wielgus, Maciek;Wong, George N.;Wu, Qingwen;Yoon, Doosoo;Young, André;Young, Ken;Younsi, Ziri;Yuan, Feng;Yuan, Ye-Fei;Zensus, J. Anton;Zhao, Guang-Yao;Zhao, Shan-Shan;Fermi Large Area Telescope Collaboration;Principe, G.;Giroletti, M.;D'Ammando, F.;Orienti, M.;H. E. S. S. Collaboration;Abdalla, H.;Adam, R.;Aharonian, F.;Benkhali, F. Ait;Angüner, E. O.;Arcaro, C.;Armand, C.;Armstrong, T.;Ashkar, H.;Backes, M.;Baghmanyan, V.;Barbosa Martins, V.;Barnacka, A.;Barnard, M.;Becherini, Y.;Berge, D.;Bernlöhr, K.;Bi, B.;Böttcher, M.;Boisson, C.;Bolmont, J.;de Lavergne, M. De Bony;Breuhaus, M.;Brun, F.;Brun, P.;Bryan, M.;Büchele, M.;Bulik, T.;Bylund, T.;Caroff, S.;Carosi, A.;Casanova, S.;Chand, T.;Chen, A.;Cotter, G.;Curyło, M.;Damascene Mbarubucyeye, J.;Davids, I. D.;Davies, J.;Deil, C.;Devin, J.;Dewilt, P.;Dirson, L.;Djannati-Ataï, A.;Dmytriiev, A.;Donath, A.;Doroshenko, V.;Duffy, C.;Dyks, J.;Egberts, K.;Eichhorn, F.;Einecke, S.;Emery, G.;Ernenwein, J. -P.;Feijen, K.;Fegan, S.;Fiasson, A.;de Clairfontaine, G. Fichet;Fontaine, G.;Funk, S.;Füßling, M.;Gabici, S.;Gallant, Y. A.;Giavitto, G.;Giunti, L.;Glawion, D.;Glicenstein, J. F.;Gottschall, D.;Grondin, M. -H.;Hahn, J.;Haupt, M.;Hermann, G.;Hinton, J. A.;Hofmann, W.;Hoischen, C.;Holch, T. L.;Holler, M.;Hörbe, M.;Horns, D.;Huber, D.;Jamrozy, M.;Jankowsky, D.;Jankowsky, F.;Jardin-Blicq, A.;Joshi, V.;Jung-Richardt, I.;Kasai, E.;Kastendieck, M. A.;Katarzyński, K.;Katz, U.;Khangulyan, D.;Khélifi, B.;Klepser, S.;Kluźniak, W.;Komin, Nu.;Konno, R.;Kosack, K.;Kostunin, D.;Kreter, M.;Lamanna, G.;Lemière, A.;Lemoine-Goumard, M.;Lenain, J. -P.;Levy, C.;Lohse, T.;Lypova, I.;Mackey, J.;Majumdar, J.;Malyshev, D.;Malyshev, D.;Marandon, V.;Marchegiani, P.;Marcowith, A.;Mares, A.;Martí-Devesa, G.;Marx, R.;Maurin, G.;Meintjes, P. J.;Meyer, M.;Moderski, R.;Mohamed, M.;Mohrmann, L.;Montanari, A.;Moore, C.;Morris, P.;Moulin, E.;Muller, J.;Murach, T.;Nakashima, K.;Nayerhoda, A.;de Naurois, M.;Ndiyavala, H.;Niederwanger, F.;Niemiec, J.;Oakes, L.;O'Brien, P.;Odaka, H.;Ohm, S.;Olivera-Nieto, L.;de Ona Wilhelmi, E.;Ostrowski, M.;Panter, M.;Panny, S.;Parsons, R. D.;Peron, G.;Peyaud, B.;Piel, Q.;Pita, S.;Poireau, V.;Noel, A. Priyana;Prokhorov, D. A.;Prokoph, H.;Pühlhofer, G.;Punch, M.;Quirrenbach, A.;Rauth, R.;Reichherzer, P.;Reimer, A.;Reimer, O.;Remy, Q.;Renaud, M.;Rieger, F.;Rinchiuso, L.;Romoli, C.;Rowell, G.;Rudak, B.;Ruiz-Velasco, E.;Sahakian, V.;Sailer, S.;Sanchez, D. A.;Santangelo, A.;Sasaki, M.;Scalici, M.;Schutte, H. M.;Schwanke, U.;Schwemmer, S.;Seglar-Arroyo, M.;Senniappan, M.;Seyffert, A. S.;Shafi, N.;Shiningayamwe, K.;Simoni, R.;Sinha, A.;Sol, H.;Specovius, A.;Spencer, S.;Spir-Jacob, M.;Stawarz, Ł.;Sun, L.;Steenkamp, R.;Stegmann, C.;Steinmassl, S.;Steppa, C.;Takahashi, T.;Tavernier, T.;Taylor, A. M.;Terrier, R.;Tiziani, D.;Tluczykont, M.;Tomankova, L.;Trichard, C.;Tsirou, M.;Tuffs, R.;Uchiyama, Y.;van der Walt, D. J.;van Eldik, C.;van Rensburg, C.;van Soelen, B.;Vasileiadis, G.;Veh, J.;Venter, C.;Vincent, P.;Vink, J.;Völk, H. J.;Vuillaume, T.;Wadiasingh, Z.;Wagner, S. J.;Watson, J.;Werner, F.;White, R.;Wierzcholska, A.;Wong, Yu Wun;Yusafzai, A.;Zacharias, M.;Zanin, R.;Zargaryan, D.;Zdziarski, A. A.;Zech, A.;Zhu, S. J.;Zorn, J.;Zouari, S.;Żywucka, N.;MAGIC Collaboration;Acciari, V. A.;Ansoldi, S.;Antonelli, L. A.;Engels, A. Arbet;Artero, M.;Asano, K.;Baack, D.;Babić, A.;Baquero, A.;de Almeida, U. Barres;Barrio, J. A.;Becerra González, J.;Bednarek, W.;Bellizzi, L.;Bernardini, E.;Bernardos, M.;Berti, A.;Besenrieder, J.;Bhattacharyya, W.;Bigongiari, C.;Biland, A.;Blanch, O.;Bonnoli, G.;Bošnjak, Ž.;Busetto, G.;Carosi, R.;Ceribella, G.;Cerruti, M.;Chai, Y.;Chilingarian, A.;Cikota, S.;Colak, S. M.;Colombo, E.;Contreras, J. L.;Cortina, J.;Covino, S.;D'Amico, G.;D'Elia, V.;da Vela, P.;Dazzi, F.;de Angelis, A.;de Lotto, B.;Delfino, M.;Delgado, J.;Delgado Mendez, C.;Depaoli, D.;di Pierro, F.;di Venere, L.;Do Souto Espiñeira, E.;Dominis Prester, D.;Donini, A.;Dorner, D.;Doro, M.;Elsaesser, D.;Ramazani, V. Fallah;Fattorini, A.;Ferrara, G.;Fonseca, M. V.;Font, L.;Fruck, C.;Fukami, S.;García López, R. J.;Garczarczyk, M.;Gasparyan, S.;Gaug, M.;Giglietto, N.;Giordano, F.;Gliwny, P.;Godinović, N.;Green, J. G.;Green, D.;Hadasch, D.;Hahn, A.;Heckmann, L.;Herrera, J.;Hoang, J.;Hrupec, D.;Hütten, M.;Inada, T.;Inoue, S.;Ishio, K.;Iwamura, Y.;Jiménez, I.;Jormanainen, J.;Jouvin, L.;Kajiwara, Y.;Karjalainen, M.;Kerszberg, D.;Kobayashi, Y.;Kubo, H.;Kushida, J.;Lamastra, A.;Lelas, D.;Leone, F.;Lindfors, E.;Lombardi, S.;Longo, F.;López-Coto, R.;López-Moya, M.;López-Oramas, A.;Loporchio, S.;Machado de Oliveira Fraga, B.;Maggio, C.;Majumdar, P.;Makariev, M.;Mallamaci, M.;Maneva, G.;Manganaro, M.;Mannheim, K.;Maraschi, L.;Mariotti, M.;Martínez, M.;Mazin, D.;Menchiari, S.;Mender, S.;Mićanović, S.;Miceli, D.;Miener, T.;Minev, M.;Miranda, J. M.;Mirzoyan, R.;Molina, E.;Moralejo, A.;Morcuende, D.;Moreno, V.;Moretti, E.;Neustroev, V.;Nigro, C.;Nilsson, K.;Nishijima, K.;Noda, K.;Nozaki, S.;Ohtani, Y.;Oka, T.;Otero-Santos, J.;Paiano, S.;Palatiello, M.;Paneque, D.;Paoletti, R.;Paredes, J. M.;Pavletić, L.;Peñil, P.;Perennes, C.;Persic, M.;Moroni, P. G. Prada;Prandini, E.;Priyadarshi, C.;Puljak, I.;Rhode, W.;Ribó, M.;Rico, J.;Righi, C.;Rugliancich, A.;Saha, L.;Sahakyan, N.;Saito, T.;Sakurai, S.;Satalecka, K.;Saturni, F. G.;Schleicher, B.;Schmidt, K.;Schweizer, T.;Sitarek, J.;Šnidarić, I.;Sobczynska, D.;Spolon, A.;Stamerra, A.;Strom, D.;Strzys, M.;Suda, Y.;Surić, T.;Takahashi, M.;Tavecchio, F.;Temnikov, P.;Terzić, T.;Teshima, M.;Tosti, L.;Truzzi, S.;Tutone, A.;Ubach, S.;van Scherpenberg, J.;Vanzo, G.;Vazquez Acosta, M.;Ventura, S.;Verguilov, V.;Vigorito, C. F.;Vitale, V.;Vovk, I.;Will, M.;Wunderlich, C.;Zarić, D.;VERITAS Collaboration;Adams, C. B.;Benbow, W.;Brill, A.;Capasso, M.;Christiansen, J. L.;Chromey, A. J.;Daniel, M. K.;Errando, M.;Farrell, K. A.;Feng, Q.;Finley, J. P.;Fortson, L.;Furniss, A.;Gent, A.;Giuri, C.;Hassan, T.;Hervet, O.;Holder, J.;Hughes, G.;Humensky, T. B.;Jin, W.;Kaaret, P.;Kertzman, M.;Kieda, D.;Kumar, S.;Lang, M. J.;Lundy, M.;Maier, G.;Moriarty, P.;Mukherjee, R.;Nieto, D.;Nievas-Rosillo, M.;O'Brien, S.;Ong, R. A.;Otte, A. N.;Patel, S.;Pfrang, K.;Pohl, M.;Prado, R. R.;Pueschel, E.;Quinn, J.;Ragan, K.;Reynolds, P. T.;Ribeiro, D.;Richards, G. T.;Roache, E.;Rulten, C.;Ryan, J. L.;Santander, M.;Sembroski, G. H.;Shang, R.;Weinstein, A.;Williams, D. A.;Williamson, T. J.;Eavn Collaboration;Hirota, Tomoya;Cui, Lang;Niinuma, Kotaro;Ro, Hyunwook;Sakai, Nobuyuki;Sawada-Satoh, Satoko;Wajima, Kiyoaki;Wang, Na;Liu, Xiang;Yonekura, Yoshinori
Journal: 
The Astrophysical Journal
Publication type: 
Article
Volume: 
911
Pages: 
L11
Abstract: 
In 2017, the Event Horizon Telescope (EHT) Collaboration succeeded in capturing the first direct image of the center of the M87 galaxy. The asymmetric ring morphology and size are consistent with theoretical expectations for a weakly accreting supermassive black hole of mass ∼6.5 × 10<SUP>9</SUP>M<SUB>⊙</SUB>. The EHTC also partnered with several international facilities in space and on the ground, to arrange an extensive, quasi-simultaneous multi-wavelength campaign. This Letter presents the results and analysis of this campaign, as well as the multi-wavelength data as a legacy data repository. We captured M87 in a historically low state, and the core flux dominates over HST-1 at high energies, making it possible to combine core flux constraints with the more spatially precise very long baseline interferometry data. We present the most complete simultaneous multi-wavelength spectrum of the active nucleus to date, and discuss the complexity and caveats of combining data from different spatial scales into one broadband spectrum. We apply two heuristic, isotropic leptonic single-zone models to provide insight into the basic source properties, but conclude that a structured jet is necessary to explain M87's spectrum. We can exclude that the simultaneous γ-ray emission is produced via inverse Compton emission in the same region producing the EHT mm-band emission, and further conclude that the γ-rays can only be produced in the inner jets (inward of HST-1) if there are strongly particle-dominated regions. Direct synchrotron emission from accelerated protons and secondaries cannot yet be excluded.
Database: 
ADS
URL: 
https://ui.adsabs.harvard.edu/#abs/2021ApJ...911L..11E/abstract
ADS Bibcode: 
2021ApJ...911L..11E
Keywords: 
Active galactic nuclei;Radio cores;Low-luminosity active galactic nuclei;High energy astrophysics;Astrophysical black holes;Accretion;Astrophysics - High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena;Astrophysics - Cosmology and Nongalactic Astrophysics;Astrophysics - Astrophysics of Galaxies